Easy Homemade Healthy Marshmallows (no corn syrup!) (2024)

These easy homemade healthy marshmallows have no corn syrup and are made with just 3 simple ingredients. Sweetened with honey and thickened with protein-rich gelatin, this homemade marshmallow recipe offers the same nostalgic texture as store-bought marshmallows but with a wholesome and nourishing twist. You'll love these irresistibly soft and fluffy pillows of sweetness - perfect to top your hot cocoa or roast over a cozy fire.

If you haven't ventured into making homemade marshmallows - these will rock your world! If you've never experienced the joy of biting into your own homemade marshmallows, these will rock your world!

Marshmallows are pretty forgiving when it comes to candy making (and yes, they are a candy!) so this is the perfect way to get your feet wet. And although you do have to be careful with the hot honey syrup, making homemade marshmallow recipe is quite simple to pull together.

And with 4 simple marshmallow ingredients that you likely have on hand, you're already well on your way to making the best healthy marshmallows.

Looking for more healthy sweet treat recipes? Check out condensed milk recipe, bedtime gummies, and gluten-free crepes. 

Recipe Overview

• Prep and Cook Time: 35 minutes to prep and cook and 4 hours to set
• Cooking Method: Stove-top
• Dietary Info: Gluten-free, Grain-free, Dairy-free
• Tools Needed: Saucepan, Stand mixer, Sheet pan
• Skill Level: Moderate

Why you'll love Healthy Marshmallows

Suitable for dietary needs - These honey marshmallows come with health benefits from high protein in the collagen to zero refined sugar. Truly, healthy marshmallows you'll feel good about making and eating!

Versatile serving options - Enjoy your own marshmallows just as you would store-bought marshmallows. You can make them into mini marshmallows or make them nice and jumbo-sized!

No special equipment needed: You don't need anything fancy to make perfectly fluffy marshmallows.

💭Fun Fact: Traditionally marshmallows have been made with marshmallow root, which is a perennial herb that is known in folk medicine to treat digestive and respiratory conditions. It naturally contains mucilage which was largely responsible to thicken this confection.

Marshmallow Ingredients

• Gelatin: The most important ingredient in homemade marshmallows as it serves as the base in giving them that stretchy, gooey texture. My favorite gelatin for marshmallows is grass-fed gelatin from Perfect Supplements.
• Water: Used to bloom the gelatin and kick start the setting process.
• Honey: This is the sweetener of choice and used to replace high fructose corn syrup. It's a healthier alternative and works exceptionally well in healthy marshmallows, giving the perfect amount of sweetness.
• Arrowroot powder: Used to dust the marshmallows, making them easier to handle. You can use tapioca starch in a pinch. In order for these healthy homemade marshmallows to remain gluten-free and better for you, I would refrain from using flour, corn starch, or potato starch.

See the recipe card for exact quantities.

Substitutions and Variations

• True Vanilla - My favorite add-in is vanilla bean, and I prefer the powder as it's super concentrated and gives the lovely brown specks of vanilla bean.
• Try a different sweetener - Try maple syrup to give it more robust flavor. Learn more about healthier choices when it comes to unrefined sugars.
• Food extracts - Vanilla extract is always a classy choice but any real food extracts will work. I recommend adding them toward the end of the whipping process. Try hazelnut or almond extract, peppermint extract, coconut for a tropical flare, or a touch of espresso.

Make it using Ancestral Wisdom

Staying true to the heart of what Prepare and Nourish is all about, there are ways to ensure you get the maximum nutrition in this healthy marshmallows recipe by following ancestral and traditional dietary philosophy. Check out these simple tips to make this recipe nutrient-dense.

Use gelatin from grass-fed cows. Bovine gelatin from Perfect Supplements is my favorite gelatin for marshmallows. It's great in quality, price, and sustainability. Use code PREPARE10 for a 10% off discount.

Know your sugars. I love using honey to make healthy marshmallows but you can use any syrup-like natural sweetener. Be sure to follow this guide for the best unrefined sugars.

How to Make Healthy Marshmallows

The complete printable recipe is below in the recipe card for your convenience. Follow these simple step-by-step instructions for the best results.

Step 1. Bloom gelatin

Add your favorite gelatin for marshmallows to the bowl of the stand mixer. Add water and quickly whisk to combine. Set aside for the gelatin to "bloom" or thicken slightly.

Step 2. Heat honey

In a heavy-bottomed saucepan, heat honey and remaining water. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat, and gently simmer, undisturbed, for another 12 minutes on medium heat.

💭Pro tip: Keep a close eye on the honey mixture so it doesn't boil over. It will start to bubble and rise but keep the heat on medium or medium-low to maintain proper temperature.

Step 3. Whisk on low speed

Turn the stand mixer with a whisk attachment on low speed to break apart the bloomed gelatin. Gently, pour the honey mixture in a thin stream, ensuring it pours down the sides of the bowl and not directly into the gelatin mixture.

Step 4. Beat on high speed

Once all honey mixture has been added to the gelatin, increase the mixer to medium-high speed or high speed and whisk until it turns to marshmallow fluff consistency, approximately 10 minutes.

See Also

Taco Potatoes - Life In The LofthouseCheesesteak Tortellini in Rich Provolone SauceSoft Pretzel Bites with Vegan Cheese SauceHow to make Strawberry Crème Frappuccino Starbucks

💭Pro tip: Continue to beat until the mixture is very stiff and the marshmallow fluff has cooled to lukewarm. If adding any food flavoring, add it towards the end of the whisking. 

Step 5. Spread marshmallow fluff

Transfer the marshmallow mixture into a shallow baking dish lined with parchment paper and dusted with arrowroot powder. Spread evenly with a flat offset spatula. You want to do this step promptly as you don't want the gelatin to set in the bowl, making the mixture stiff. Set aside at room temperature to completely "cure" for at least 4 hours or overnight uncovered.

Step 6. Cut marshmallows

Remove the marshmallow from the pan by pulling on the parchment paper—dust with arrowroot powder, covering the entire exposed surface area. Cut in half crosswise making two large sheets. Then cut lengthwise to make 1" strips and then crosswise to create 1" cubes. Toss all marshmallow cubes with the starch and transfer to an airtight container.

Helpful Tips for Healthy Marshmallows

Use a candy thermometer - Marshmallows are candy, so it's fitting to use a candy thermometer and cook the honey mixture until it reaches 240°F. Or just be observant and follow the cues as mentioned in the recipe directions.

Grease the knife - You may want to grease your sharp knife or pizza cutter with a neutral oil like avocado oil to allow for easier cutting.

Make mini marshmallows - Use a baking sheet with a large surface area. Spread out the marshmallow fluff as evenly as you can. After marshmallow sets, cut into smaller pieces.

Extra sweetness - Add a bit of powdered sugar into the arrowroot powder for the dusting.

Coat with starch well - To ensure that all pieces are efficiently dusted with arrowroot starch, add them a ziplock bag with the starch, seal, and shake. Remove excess starch with a fine mesh strainer.

💭Meal Prep Suggestion: The amount listed in the recipe card will be enough to add to your favorite sweet potato casserole, s'mores, and a few mugs of hot chocolate. Feel free to double the recipe for double the sweetness. 

Below are some affiliate links that may be helpful to you as you make this healthy marshmallow recipe. You can find some of these items cheaper at your local store, but having a link helps you know what you're looking for.Tools: Kitchen Aid stand mixer, hand mixer, large bowl, sheet panIngredients: bovine gelatin, real honey

Serving Suggestions

Serve healthy marshmallows as you would regular marshmallows from your local grocery store. They stand up to heat well, making them a perfect addition to gluten-free rice crispy treats, healthy hot chocolate, or just as a sweet treat during movie night.

Homemade marshmallow recipe pairing suggestions

Storage Instructions

How long do homemade healthy marshmallows last in the refrigerator?

To store: Store marshmallows in an airtight container at room temperature for a up to 4 days then transfer them to the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks.

Storage containers: These glass snap containers are perfect for storing leftover healthy marshmallows. You can also store them in wide-mouth mason jars.

Can you freeze marshmallows?

Yes, freezing marshmallows is a breeze. For longer storage you can freeze healthy marshmallows to extend their shelf life without changing the texture.

To freeze: Transfer them to a freezer-safe container with a tight-fitting lid or large freezer bag (ziplock bag works) and remove as much air as possible to avoid freezer burn and unpleasant odors seeping through. Freeze for up to 2-3 months.

To use, just pull a small amount of frozen marshmallows (they shouldn't stick) from the sealed bag or air-tight container and add them to your hot cocoa or just enjoy as a sweet treat. Seal the opened bag of marshmallows again and place in the freezer for next time.

The marshmallow ingredients in this homemade version are similar in consistency to the storebought version, allowing for perfect freezing!

Frequently Asked Questions

Looking for more related recipes? Here are some ideas:

Did you make this healthy marshmallows recipe? Please leave a ⭐ recipe rating in the recipe card below and leave a review in the comments. Thank you!💚

Printable Recipe